Finally got it, had to play with the textures also. Thanks for the help!
Code:
function Border:OnUpdate(parent, unit, status)
if status then
parent:SetBeautyBorderTexture('white')
parent:SetBeautyBorderColor(status:GetColor(unit))
else
parent:SetBeautyBorderTexture('default')
parent:SetBeautyBorderColor(1,1,1)
end
end